Skip to main content
BrewMarkBREWMARK

Which to buy · Every setting

Comandante C40 MK4 vs Timemore C3

The reference hand grinder against the value one.

Comandante C40 MK4

Comandante

C40 MK4

About $299

Timemore C3

Timemore

C3

About $79

Which to buy

Choose the

C40 MK4 if you…

  • want a 40 g jar; two come in the box
  • want Comandante's Nitro Blade burrs, made in Germany
  • may want finer espresso steps later — Comandante sells a Red Clix axle for that

Choose the

C3 if you…

  • want Timemore's 38 mm S2C660 conical burrs, which it rates from espresso to French press
  • may move towards espresso — Timemore makes C3 ESP models with a finer dial

Shop links are affiliate links: BrewMark earns a commission if you buy through one, at no extra cost to you. The verdicts were written without regard to it.

Timemore sells the C3 in several versions (C3, C3S, Max, ESP, Pro). The settings on this page are for the standard C3 dial.

Sources: Comandante — C40 MK4 · Comandante — FAQ · Comandante — Red Clix · Timemore — C3 series

Neither one sounds like you? See every grinder that fits how you brew →

Comandante C40 MK4 and Timemore C3 specifications compared
C40 MK4C3
BrandComandanteTimemore
ScaleClicksClicks
Dial range0 clicks – 40 clicks0 clicks – 36 clicks
BurrsConicalConical
Espresso → filter21 clicks7 clicks
Filter → coarse9.5 clicks11 clicks
Burr size—38 mm
Bean capacity40 g30 g

Burr size, weight, capacity, step and warranty are from each maker’s own pages (C40 MK4, C3); a dash means the maker doesn’t say.

The same number means different things

Both grinders use a clicks, which makes it tempting to copy a number straight across. Setting 18 clicks sits at grind index 17 on the C40 MK4 but 53.2 on the C3 — far enough apart to change the cup.

Converting a setting

If a recipe quotes a setting for one of these grinders, read across for the equivalent on the other. Rows are spaced evenly by grind size, not by dial number — on a conical burr those are not the same thing.

C40 MK4 → C3
C40 MK4C3
6 clicks8 clicks
13 clicks10 clicks
18 clicks12 clicks
22 clicks13 clicks
25 clicks14 clicks
28 clicks15 clicks
29 clicks17 clicks
30 clicks21 clicks
31 clicks23 clicks
33 clicks24 clicks
35 clicks25 clicks
37 clicks26 clicks
C3 → C40 MK4
C3C40 MK4
8 clicks6 clicks
10 clicks13 clicks
12 clicks18 clicks
13 clicks22 clicks
14 clicks25 clicks
15 clicks28 clicks
17 clicks29 clicks
19 clicks29 clicks
21 clicks30 clicks
23 clicks31 clicks
24 clicks33 clicks
25 clicks35 clicks
26 clicks37 clicks

Side by side, by brew method

Where each grinder lands for the same brew, worked out from its own dial curve.

Comandante C40 MK4 and Timemore C3 settings for every brew method
MethodC40 MK4C3
Espresso10 clicks9 clicks
Moka pot17 clicks12 clicks
AeroPress (short steep)22 clicks13 clicks
Pour over — V60 / cone27 clicks15 clicks
Siphon28 clicks15 clicks
Pour over — flat bottom28 clicks16 clicks
Steep and release — Clever / Switch29 clicks17 clicks
Drip / batch brew29 clicks17 clicks
Cupping29 clicks18 clicks
Chemex29 clicks19 clicks
French press31 clicks22 clicks
Cold brew34 clicks25 clicks
Comandante C40 MK4 vs Timemore C3 grind settings for 12 brew methods; pour over is 27 clicks on the C40 MK4 and 15 clicks on the C3.
The Comandante C40 MK4 and Timemore C3 settings side by side, as one image. Download the chart (PNG).

The shape of each dial

Where the connectors bunch, that grinder’s dial is compressed and single steps count for more. Comparing the two shapes tells you which gives finer control, and where.

Comandante C40 MK4

FINECOARSEGRIND INDEX 0–100040COMANDANTE C40 MK4 DIALEspressoV60French pressCold brew
Where the lines bunch, the dial is compressed — small moves count for more

Timemore C3

FINECOARSEGRIND INDEX 0–100036TIMEMORE C3 DIALEspressoV60French pressCold brew
Where the lines bunch, the dial is compressed — small moves count for more

Dialing in the C40 MK4

The reference hand grinder for filter, and its click scale has become a de facto standard — plenty of published recipes quote "C40 clicks" as though it were a universal unit. It is not, which is the reason this site exists. The MK4 runs coarser than most people assume relative to electric grinders: if you are converting a recipe written for a Baratza, do not simply match the number.

Dialing in the C3

The best-value hand grinder in circulation and the one most likely to be someone's first. Its range is usable across filter and immersion, with espresso possible but genuinely tedious. The C3 benefits more than most grinders from a few seconds of settling before you judge a shot or a pour — its distribution tightens noticeably once the burrs are warm.

Comandante C40 MK4 vs Timemore C3: Which to Buy + Settings